Table 1: Characteristics of
Included Studies of Measles in HIV-infected Children
|
Reference |
Dates and Location |
Study Type |
HIV and
measles patients |
Evidence Level[i] |
Study Population |
Diagnostic Method |
Comment |
|
Moss WJ et al 2002 [ii] |
1998-2000 |
Comparative
Prospective Case Control |
93 |
1b |
All children hospitalized with a
clinical diagnosis of measles in one hospital over a 33 month period.
HIV-infected and HIV-uninfected, and confirmed and unconfirmed measles cases
compared |
Clinical diagnosis (case definition
not given) followed by serological testing for virus specific IgM. |
Individual case symptoms and
characteristics not published. 93 HIV-infected and 453 HIV-uninfected children
with confirmed measles. |
|
1990-1991 |
Retrospective |
6 |
2b |
All HIV-infected children with
measles from hospital discharge and outpatient records over a two year period
|
Serological by measles specific IgM, epidemiological
or post-mortem |
Unclear how many different hospitals
were included in the record search |
|
|
2
year period |
Cohort |
4 |
3b |
All HIV-infected children hospitalized
with measles in one hospital over a two year period |
Serological by 4x increase in measles
haemagglutination inhibition antibody and measles specific IgM or post-mortem |
One case excluded as indeterminant
HIV status. One case excluded as unclear method of diagnosis |
|
|
1986-1987 |
Epidemiology
Report |
6 |
3b |
All cases of measles in HIV-infected
patients in the |
Serological, epidemiological or post-mortem
histopathological analysis |
3 cases also reported by Krasinski et
al. Additional information for one case found from a case report of the same
patient.[vi] |
|
|
de Carvalho V
et al 2003 [vii] |
1997-1998 |
Prospective
Cohort |
5 |
3b |
Prospective study of 40 children with
HIV over 11 months |
Serological (presence of IgM
antibody) or epidemiological confirmation |
|
|
Kaplan LJ et al. 1992 [viii] |
1989-1990 |
Cohort |
2 |
3b |
All immunocompromised children hospitalized
with a clinical diagnosis of measles within 2 hospitals |
Serological confirmation for 4x rise
in IgG or presence of IgM antibody |
Also one case of measles in an
HIV-infected adult reported. |
[i] Phillips
B, Ball C, Sackett D, Badenoch D, Straus S, Haynes B, Dawes M Oxford Centre for
Evidence-based Medicine Levels of Evidence http://www.cebm.net/?o=1023
[ii]
Moss WJ. Monze M. Ryon JJ. Quinn TC.
[iii]
Palumbo P, Hoyt L, Demasio K, Oleske J, Connor E. Population-based study of
measles and measles immunization in HIV infected children. Pediatr Infect Dis J 1992; 11:1008 14.
[iv]
Krasinski K, Borkowsky W. Measles and measles immunity in children infected
with human immunodeficiency virus. JAMA
1989 261:2512 6.
[v] Centers
for Disease Control and Prevention. Measles in HIV-infected children,
[vi]
Markowitz LE,
[vii] de
Carvalho V, Marinoni LP, Martins LF, Taniguchi1 K, da Cruz CR, Bertogna1 J,
Neto JF Measles in Children With HIV Infection: Report of Five Cases Brazilian Journal of Infectious Diseases
2003 7(5) 346-352
[viii]
Kaplan LJ. Daum RS. Smaron M. McCarthy CA. Severe measles in immunocompromised
patients. JAMA. 267(9):1237-41, 1992 Mar 4.